Prices from 51 stores, collected
Chocolate Shake vs Caramel Frappé
The Caramel Frappé had a median price $0.10 lower. The Caramel Frappé has 160 fewer calories.
| Chocolate Shake | Caramel Frappé | |
|---|---|---|
| Median price | $5.59 (Medium) | $5.49 (Medium) |
| Stores listing it | 37 | 45 |
| Meal median | No meal listed | No meal listed |
| Calories | 650 cal | 490 cal |
| Protein (small) | 12 g | 7 g |
| Total fat (small) | 14 g | 17 g |
| Sodium (small) | 250 mg | 80 mg |
| Carbohydrates (small) | 85 g | 60 g |
| Sugars (small) | 67 g | 53 g |
| Allergens | Milk | Milk |
Highlighted: lower price, fewer calories, less fat or sodium, more protein. Prices are Uber Eats menu medians from Sep 13, 2026; nutrition is McDonald's USA data.
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper, the Chocolate Shake or the Caramel Frappé?
On delivery menus at the stores we sampled on Sep 13, 2026, the Caramel Frappé had the lower median price ($5.49), $0.10 less. Prices at your restaurant will differ.
Which has fewer calories?
The Caramel Frappé, with 160 fewer calories.
Other comparisons
Big Mac vs Quarter Pounder with CheeseBig Mac vs McDoubleQuarter Pounder with Cheese vs Double Quarter Pounder with CheeseMcDouble vs Double CheeseburgerMcCrispy vs McChickenMcCrispy vs Spicy McCrispyChicken McNuggets (10 pc) vs Chicken McNuggets (20 pc)Chicken McNuggets (6 pc) vs McCrispy Strips (3 pc)OREO McFlurry vs Hot Fudge SundaeCaramel Frappé vs Iced Coffee